Giving Money To Beggars
Posted by Cap in Even More Ramblings |The few times I’ve given money to beggars, it’s usually to people who are clearly disabled. A bit discriminating, I know. Most of the time I’m reluctant to give money to beggars — especially if they’re asking for it. It’s kind of weird, if they’re not asking for money, then they’ll have a better shot at getting it from me.
Now, I don’t have anything against giving. I prefer to donate to reputable charities though, since they can better determine the use of the funds than I can. That’s probably the reason why I’m reluctant to give money to beggars — I’m unsure of what they’re going to do with the money.
It seems there are always those stories about fake beggars, people that pretend they’re poor so they can get a hand-out. I always thought they were exaggerations, until I heard a story from an old friend last night.
My friend worked at a restaurant in the Costa Mesa area, and they have a frequent beggar that shows up occasionally around the restaurant. Feeling sorry for her one day, due the female beggar’s ragged appearance and what not, my friend decided to give her some food from the restaurant — since the person seemed hungry.
Right when my friend told me that, I thought she’ll tell me that the beggar refuse the food & wanted money instead, which wasn’t the case. The person thanked her for the food and ate as if it was the last meal.
Days later, my friend bumped into the same beggar, this time, wearing stylish clothes and covered with jewelry. Hmm. The “beggar” was embarrassed to be caught, gave a weak smile as a form of apology, and hurried off away from my friend’s gaze.
“I couldn’t believe it! The last time she totally looked like the real deal. Ragged clothes, messy hair, dirty fingers, etc.” my surprised friend told me.
And I guess I couldn’t believe it too, I haven’t heard many stories like this directly. It’s usually an indirect story from someone else, hearing it from another person.
“Now that I think about it,” my friend continued, “I’d much rather give money to those with the funny signs. You know, the guys with the signs that reads: Let’s be honest, I just want money for booze & crack.”
And that made me wonder. Are those beggars just trying to be funny, were really being honest, or just using a different tactic while on the job?
17 Comments to “Giving Money To Beggars”
Leave a Comment
YOUTUBE: Haggling with Russell Peters »
« Four Things I’ll NEVER Buy







April 13th, 2006 at 8:37 am
I always give to the guys with stories like “Listen, man…I’m just trying to get a 40oz.” Gotta love the honesty!
April 13th, 2006 at 8:47 am
Actual sign spotted in my city:
“Entire family killed by ninjas — need money for karate lessons.”
April 13th, 2006 at 10:30 am
You need to stop by berkeley… one out of the many “regulars” I used to see was a middel-aged woman carrying bags and bags of Lord knows what. She used to walk around the streets next to the dorms asking students for bus fare to go back home. To this day, I have never seen her on a bus.
Giving to organizations is a lot smarter…
April 13th, 2006 at 10:40 am
I know someone who once tried panhandling as a social experiment. He raked in more money in a day doing that than I do as a software engineer (and I’m paid pretty darn well!). Of course, he donated his take to charity.
But I don’t blame anyone who hesitates to give to panhandlers because you have no way of knowing where the money’s going–maybe to food and shelter, maybe to booze, or maybe to some rich guy who makes more money standing outside with a sign than actually working. The truly needy will take food and drink just as readily, so if you have either on you when you spot one, offer that instead.
April 13th, 2006 at 11:00 am
We went on a trip to Louisiana a few years ago and on the way down there, on the other side of the highway, at a rest stop these people had a sign saying they were broke down and needed money to get home.
3 days later, on the way back home we saw the same people on the other side of the highway this time, with the same sign!
With churches, shelters, day to day job services, DHS, etc. there really isn’t any reason for people to beg on the streets.
April 13th, 2006 at 1:25 pm
With churches, shelters, day to day job services, DHS, etc. there really isn’t any reason for people to beg on the streets.
–
You can’t be serious. Some shelters are over-crowded while church funds are drained. There’s plenty of reason. Agreed, that some beggars are ‘fake’ or reeling in more money than actually working.. though.
April 13th, 2006 at 3:55 pm
I used to panhandle when I was in college. I would stand on a downtown street corner and say my dog was in the pound and needed money to get her out. Her worked better then him. Even people that knew me and knew I didn’t have a dog would give me money because I was good at it. My nickels, dimes and quarters bought a lot of beer. The bar tennders gave me free ones because they wanted all the change.
Life was good.
April 13th, 2006 at 8:50 pm
I guess fake panhandling isn’t as rare as I thought? heh. That’s some extreme examples & actual practice there…
April 14th, 2006 at 9:53 am
I usually give to the disabled (people you can see are blind, amputees, etc.) but stay away from others.
I eat out frequently and often have “doggie bags” from restaurants, especially when I’m eating out in big cities downtown areas where beggars are frequent. I have never met a beggar who wasn’t very grateful to get a nutrigrain bar you have in your coat pocket or a doggie bag…consider that sometime if it’s a kind of dish that wouldn’t be disrespectful to give to someone.
April 14th, 2006 at 1:36 pm
I think of my charity as I do my investments: what am I (as a member of a wider society) getting from this? If I give to an individual on the street, I can never be sure. But if I give to an organization, such as the shelters in town, or Heifer International, then I know that the money will be used in a responsible manner to help improve my community or another community.
But if I’m going to give something to the guy on the street, I’d rather give to the guy who does something to earn it, so I’m more likely to toss change into the street musician’s cup or the mime’s hat than give money to stranger who just asks for it. I have given food to street people, though, and it was always well received.
April 14th, 2006 at 3:08 pm
i guess i’m a bit jaded by panhandlers. i went to school in berkeley which could quite possibly be the beggar capital of the world. i once got asked by a man outside of a 7-11 for some change because he “hadn’t had a bite to eat in days”. I said no but when I was in 7-11 I bought him a muffin and gave it to him on my way out. he looked at me and said “i don’t want this. don’t you have any cash?” i said no and he immediately went into the 7-11 to try and get the money back for it.
i guess i don’t learn my lesson because i have tons of stories of falling for their crap. if they really needed assistance there are plenty of churches, soup kitchens and shelters that are available to them to help them get back on their feet.
April 19th, 2006 at 6:33 am
I usually give money to beggars on the streets. It all depends on the person. The people who simply ask for money, with no particular reason, don’t get any money from me. I usually give to the disabled, story tellers, and funny beggars because they do more than simply ask for a dollar.
When you donate to your favorite charity, do you know exactly how much of the dollar goes directly to the cause?
April 21st, 2006 at 10:31 pm
I usually refer to the numbers given at charitynavigator.com, though certain religious organization won’t be found there…
here’s that ninja one that maribeth mentioned. heh, must be a popular sign.
April 28th, 2006 at 9:02 pm
fake beggars may be part of media agenda and note that part of what you give to charitable organisation is paid for admin overhead
March 28th, 2007 at 8:44 am
years ago, a man used to beg right off the expressway near our home. My young daughter wanted to give him food (he was holding a sign that said he was hungry), just having come from the grocers, that was ready to eat, were bananas. She offered him our bananas and he laughed, said no thanks and went back to scoping out other cars. I never give to panhandlers. I love sending money to local food banks and such.
November 8th, 2009 at 12:49 am
Oh heck, if it were me, I’d sure want someone to give me a buck.
I’ve never had to beg, but I may try it since it worked for some posters.
Usually, I don’t give beggars anything because I hate it when they disturb me, run up and get it my face and beg.
They don’t normally want you to buy them a snack.
But I have a policy that if a dollar comes my way accidently, I pay it back to the next needy person I see.
Tonight a donut clerk gave me a free donut, so I might have ninety cents for someone soon.