Why Do People Need More Than One Credit Card?
Posted by Cap in Credit Related |A few days ago, I was in San Fransisco with a friend, eating burgers at a Korean/Japaneses/Asian fusion (whatever that is) restaurant called Namu (Nothing beats burgers at an asian restaurant. heh. Yelp reviews can be found here).
Being the awesome friend that he is, my friend paid for the lunch with his semi-recently acquired Citi mTVU student credit card. This credit card was his first credit card and it was none other than yours truly that recommended the card to him.
“Ah, so you’re using the card now eh?” I said to the friend calculating the tip amount. “Do you like the card?”
“It’s great! I’ve racked up quite a bit of points already.” my friend told me as he writes down a 15% tip.
The funny thing about all of this, is that my friend is at least a year or so older than me. He is almost out of graduate school, and will soon be making a nice six figure salary. Besides his student loan, which is also of a sickening six figure amount, my friend has never been in debt.
It was only about a half a year ago, when I had lunch with him that he pulled out his debit card to pay for his lunch.
“Why don’t you use your credit card?” I asked him.
“Oh. Um, I don’t have one.” he told me nonchalantly.
My jaw would have dropped, but this was not the first time I came across a situation like this. Despite the media report, there is still quite a good amount of college/graduate students without a credit card — and from my experiences, that’s probably a good thing.
I have already mentioned that I love credit cards (even though it is the very thing that got me into the debt mess), but that doesn’t mean I despise people that use debit cards. Like my friend here, I have many other friends that didn’t get a credit card until a certain annoying friend told them to. All of these friends that don’t have a credit card have an interesting difference to my other friends with credit cards.
What’s this difference?
You’ve probably already guessed it: None of them have high-interest consumer debt.
And so, I went ahead and recommended to these friends that don’t have a credit card to get a credit card. heh.
No no, not because I want them to get into debt — I’m not that petty, dammit. I recommended a credit card to them because I know fully well that they already have the capability to manage their cash wisely, and so I trust that they will also manage their credit wisely.
They have already been paying their purchases in full for years, so switching to a different paying method should not affect their spending habits.
Anyway, that’s not the point of this post.
As we walked out of the Asian fusion restaurant (heh) and continue to chat about the benefits of using a credit card wisely, my friend asked me this question:
Why do people need more than one credit card?
This was a really refreshing question. I was stumped a bit on the question, not because I couldn’t immediately think of a reason on why people use different cards (mileage, gas, rebates, cash back, etc.), but more so because of whom the question is from.
Here was a guy who has never had a credit card until recently. He’s enjoying the free rewards from the purchases as he diligently pays off his bill every month. He is content with the credit card that he has, and to him, having one credit card is more than plenty. He does not look forward to dealing with more than one bill, nor does he care to juggle various reward cards to get the maximum reward/cash-back.
It is interesting that for awhile, I thought it was normal and perfectly acceptable for people to have many different types of credit cards — all the while, my friend can’t even fathom the reason why people need more than one card.
“Hmm. To be honest, most people probably don’t need more than one credit card.” I finally answered my friend. “There’s plenty of good reasons to have more than one credit card, since you can utilize different card for different transactions. But yeah… at the end, having more than one credit card, or even more than a few, is probably unnecessary.”
I proceeded to tell him the usual story about the average household credit card debt, and how people get one card to transfer the debt from one to another. And then I told him about how people unknowingly get high interest card, neglect to pay in full and became undisciplined in their spending with credit cards.
“So as you can see, credit card can really be a world of trouble for many people.” I told my friend. “The only reason why I recommended them to you is because I know you won’t abuse them.”
And I’ll continue to stick with these guidelines when I recommend credit cards.
If you already have more than one credit card, ask yourself this question:
- Why do I need more than one credit card?
Depending on your answer, you may be able to see where you stand financially.
If you are considering getting a credit card, ask yourself these questions:
- Why do I need a credit card?
- What would I use for it for?
- Will I pay my balances in full?
Educate yourself with the resources available. Learn to utilize cash wisely before you try credit. If you have trouble managing your cash flow, you will most likely have trouble with a credit card. Don’t know which card to choose? Ask around!
Although I love credit cards, you can probably get by these days without ever touching one. Don’t get suck into the idea that you need a credit card. Don’t get more than one credit card because you think you should. Lastly, whatever you do, don’t get a credit card just because the cashier asked you if you wanted one.
26 Comments to “Why Do People Need More Than One Credit Card?”
Leave a Comment
Recent Stuff on The Mint Blog »
« Getting Hungry After You Brush & Floss







June 11th, 2007 at 7:51 pm
One reason that I like to have an additional credit card is that if I’m traveling and will be reimbursed for the expenses it’s nice to have them all in one place, that’s separate from my personal expenses. Another reason that people often have more than one credit card is that if you’re a good customer (even if you’re a “deadbeat”) it can be really hard to cancel an account.
June 11th, 2007 at 8:49 pm
cami, hard to cancel a card? That’s just laziness. You might not want to go through the hassle, but if you really wanted to cancel a card, you can. That’s after you take a few things in to consideration, like how long the accounts been open. It might affect your credit score if you close a good standing account that’s been open for a long time.
Why do people need more than one card? Maybe to maximize rewards but in how much will that really gain you year to year? The difference between 2% on a regular rewards card and 6% on a gas rebate card is like 50 bucks a year if you buy $1500 of gas. That might be worth it if you really want it, but some might not like to go through the hassle.
June 11th, 2007 at 8:54 pm
Why I currently have 2 Credit Cards
1. Rewards
2. Credit Score
June 12th, 2007 at 6:23 am
I guess my 9 CC’s is a bit high then? Only one has a balance..it’s 0% and is mostly eye surgery and hotels for this summers vacation.
I think about canceling some, but, just don’t do it. where’s my doughnut.
June 12th, 2007 at 8:54 am
I don’t know off-hand how many credit cards I have, but only three live in my wallet. I carry around a Discover card, because I like the rewards, and a Visa card with rewards I like for places that don’t take Discover. (The third one is a Visa associated with a particular store, and I pretty much only use it at that store, again, for reward points. I shop there frequently enough to just leave the card there.)
My other credit cards really were obtained for various discounts, and are at home hanging out with my credit score. Some of them should be canceled (and one is for emergency purposes–i.e., if my wallet gets lost, I’ll still have a credit card until everything gets straightened out).
June 12th, 2007 at 9:24 am
I’m one of those people who think, you can get by without a credit card. (if you have a good savings acct)
I think for the most part people that have more than one is because of the enticing advertisers. One card have 0% interest another have rebates another has airline miles. These companies are competing for your business. At the end of the day, you maybe have 3 cards. Do not jump ship. These airline mile cards force you to make purchases giving you the feeling that one day you will have a free trip. Before you had that card I’m sure you was not thinking about a free airline ticket. I rather just pay for a ticket instead of accumulating points by then psychologically you have already paid for the ticket 3 times over.
Stick with one card, if not any.
June 12th, 2007 at 10:51 am
I have 3 cards:
1) Rewards card thats 5% cash back on groceries and gas, 1% on all else.
2) Travel card thats 2-3% for flights and trips and 1% on everything else
3) Subaru mastercard thats 3% off on everything, except I have to use the rewards toward Subaru stuff (convenient, since that’s what I drive)
I put all my groceries and gas on #1, travel on #2 and everything else on #3. If I go over the max annual rewards on the subaru card, I start using one of the 1% cash back ones.
Using 3 cards helps me get 2-3% back on instead of 1%… which makes a big difference when I spend 40k/year.
June 12th, 2007 at 11:49 am
ATPFB, I wouldn’t say it’s laziness, perhaps it has more to do with the fact that I am not a confrontational person. I have one card that I’ve tried to cancel several times, each time they give me something, more miles, vouchers, etc. I actually get more rewards from trying to cancel the card than I do from purchases! And yes, one of my cards is the oldest record on my credit report so I keep it around, but since it has a piddly credit line and mediocre rewards I don’t use it.
However, I will say that I only carry around one credit card, unless I’m using my Amex because like Beth mentioned with her Discover card, it isn’t taken everywhere.
June 12th, 2007 at 12:44 pm
I think it’s good to have a credit card, if you can handle it, for car rental, for buyer’s insurance (your credit card company can help you deal with bad sellers) and for emergencies.
I think it’s good to have two credit cards so if something is wonky with one, you have another to rely on. For example, sometimes a large purchase will freak out a credit card company and they’ll put a hold on purchases until they can get in touch with you. Or sometimes there’s just a mistake.
I have three credit cards:
1) awesome rewards card for groceries, gas, and pharmacies
2) good rewards card for home improvement and other stuff
3) low-interest card from my credit union, in case I want to carry a balance for a brief period or am traveling or otherwise would prefer to deal with a less slimy credit card company.
If you have a favorite shop that offers credit cards, having a credit card can get you on their mailing list, which might be nice, but most of my favorite shops just have a form you can fill out to get on their mailing list.
June 12th, 2007 at 3:09 pm
I have seven cards, each with its own story:
1. Corporate AmEx for business expenses
2. Chase Freedom for groceries (3% back)
3. Emigrant Direct for most other purchases (1.4% back to my savings account)
4. A furniture store credit card I’m using to furnish my new home (0% for two(!) years)
5. Another store credit card, from the time I got caught in a torrential downpour without an umbrella during a business trip, and had to buy an entirely new outfit (and never used again since).
6. A trusty backup credit card I’ve had since college (no annual fee, unused for about four years)
7. A new, 12-month 0% APY card I’m using to finance the renovations in my new home (or, rather, I’m charging my Emigrant card for the rewards, then transfering the balance to the 0% card).
I’ll have more in the near future as I fully intend to play the 0% rotation game indefinitely (depending on how the mortgage affects my credit score).
June 12th, 2007 at 8:57 pm
Money is just an illusion. It’s not real. It’s only worth what we say it is worth. If the government all of a sudden said we would use seashells for currency instead of bills, then we could literally wipe our a**es with $20 bills b/c they would be worth nothing. We would be putting 600 seashells on our credit cards for that new iphone instead.
Our amount of spending decides the prices of things. Consumers are the ones that decide whether the cost of real estate goes up or down. The more credit that is given to the general public = the more “money” most of us will spend with that issued credit. Inflation occurs with this spending on pieces of plastic that we can never seem to pay off, along with a rise in consumer debt. So now, we have higher prices of goods along with debts to pay, all thanks to who you ask? Why ourselves of course!
Don’t worry though, we can at least act like we’re rich. Let’s live the American Dream now and then worry about paying it back later. There are always those 401ks to cash in early at a fraction of their value.
Back to the Spurs game.
June 13th, 2007 at 7:15 am
I have found that it pays to have both a MasterCard and a Visa because some parts of the world only took one or the other (wierd, but true).
Some cards max out the reward, so it pays to switch. The “other” perks vary by card (like car rental insurance), so I keep a mix just for that.
June 13th, 2007 at 11:24 am
Between my husband and I, we have 4 cards that we use:
1. Joint Disney Chase card–used to auto-pay household bills, and for most of our joint expenses
2. My company AmEx card–issued in my name, but used only for work expenses and paid by my employer
3. My Capital One card–used very infrequently, primarily to keep it active
4. His Capital One card–again not used very often
All of these cards are paid off every month. As to why we have the Capital One Cards–this being my second marriage, I am a bit paranoid financially. I don’t want either one of us in a situation where all credit reporting and availability is based on joint accounts,just in case.
June 13th, 2007 at 12:45 pm
Sometimes it just makes sense. I’ve got 3:
1) Driver’s Edge. For everyday rewards. Cash back. Use it for gas, groceries, everything….except. After my next car purchase, this will be retired, as I plan to convert over to the “buy a used car and drive til it dies” philosophy, so my rewards will not last between purchases.
2) Kohl’s. Sometimes you can get extra discounts as long as you charge on your Kohl’s card.
3) American Express Blue. I got this one for ONE purpose. 20% off ski packages at Sugarloaf USA. That saved us a bundle! I’ll use it again next year when the snow flies!
June 13th, 2007 at 2:46 pm
I have only one card and its a Discover Card that is accepted at about, oh 75% of all businesses. Enough said. I know I know, its pathetic!
June 13th, 2007 at 3:19 pm
i think we started to get into trouble when we got more than one credit card. the reason is that i had a hard time keeping them all straight. in a household with two working parents and a hectic schedule it’s hard to stay on top of bills. especially when you have more than one type of visa. my goal is to pay off the credit cards and then only have one card that my husband and i share. much more transparency to what we spend that way and i think we’ll do a better job managing our bills/expenses.
June 13th, 2007 at 8:54 pm
One personal card is enough for me. It is for on-line purchases and emergencies only and is paid in full every time a bill is sent.
Don’t be fooled… perks, rewards and other benefits make sense on paper, but the credit companies all know that statistically, we DO spend more money when we use a card. What really, is the price of the rewards we get? My experience is that sometimes, the free things end up costing quite a bit.
June 14th, 2007 at 5:29 pm
i’m afraid of credit cards! :)
June 14th, 2007 at 10:44 pm
I just have the one, and it’s my pride and joy.
It’s a Crapital One card (they’re online service BLOWS) but I do get 1% cash back on everything I purchase. It’s not that much, but I never turn down free money. :)
Having just the one makes life way more enjoyable (as opposed to NINE). My goal is to acquire a card that’s the most rewarding to me, while only having one credit card.
June 15th, 2007 at 2:52 pm
The thing to remember here is that technology has significantly reduced the time cost of tracking multiple accounts. I spend less than twenty minutes a month on bills; ten years ago – when I was still in school, and had a greatly simplified financial situation – I would typically spend over an hour per month tracking my finances. Not only did it take longer, but my information was also less accurate (did I already write a check for that bill? Did it go through yet?). Back then, I never would have trusted myself with the rate arbitrage games I take for granted now (nor would I likely have qualified for it).
#17 – this is true, but there’s money to be made by being the outlier. The key is being honest with yourself – if you know you can’t stay disciplined enough to avoid the interest and fees, then the cards aren’t worth the effort. If you’re diligent about your bills like most of the commenters here, then the card companies are effectively paying you for the privilege of extending short-term, interest-free loans every month. Which is nice.
June 16th, 2007 at 3:25 pm
I have a number of credit cards:
1) My B of A card. This is the first card I ever had (it was MBNA then), so I keep it open for the sake of my credit score. I use this for all of my fixed bills, so that this card has the same balance every month. It helps with budgeting.
2) My Citibank card. I get good rewards on this and use it for my variable expenses.
3) A Discover card. I have 0% interest on this through the end of the year, so I keep it maxed out while the money I’d otherwise be paying it with earns 5% in a savings account.
4) A Crapital One card. I don’t like Crap One, so I only use this when traveling internationally. AFAIK, Crap One is the only credit card issuer that charges ZERO foreign currency transaction fees.
I was glad to have multiple cards a few weeks ago when someone tried to make an unauthorized charge on my Citibank card. Citibank caught it immediately, but closed my account anyway out of caution. It took them more than a week to send me a new card.
The way I see it, if you’re responsible with credit cards, it doesn’t matter if you have 1 or 10. If you aren’t responsible with credit cards, 1 is too many. I got my first card in college and have never, ever carried a balance. It works for me.
June 17th, 2007 at 5:31 pm
Using a credit card causes prople to spend more than they would if paying with actual cash. See daveramsey.com for details. I know most of u wont believe it, but studies prove credit card transactions cause you to spend 8-12% more. Why do you think Mcdonald’s now takes plastic?
June 18th, 2007 at 9:24 am
Jodi, you played the role of Debbie Downer quite nicely by kinda-sorta-but-not-really responding to Cap’s post. Instead you decided to post a few silly paragraphs about how money isn’t real. Nice. That was totally worth my time (and yours). No offense meant though. Keep spreading the good vibes.
July 3rd, 2007 at 5:53 am
It’s not necessarily a bad thing to have a few cards, but some of you folks with 7 cards might want to rethink that a little bit. Once you get more than 4-5, and especially if they are high limit cards, you might be getting hits on your credit score.
Specialty rewards cards are a great idea to use when you have the chance. I have a card for home improvements, and it gets 4% cash back on those purchases. It really adds up when you are fixing up houses to flip.
July 13th, 2007 at 4:51 pm
I have 2 credit cards for a very specific reason. I went to pick up a reserved rental car once and the place had just stopped accepting Visa because they had reneged on paying some damage claim (something like that – this is 15 years ago). The guy in front of me was 3000 miles from home, had only a Visa card and was pretty much out of luck. Fortunately, in addition to Visa I also had Amex and was able to rent my car no problem.
I’ve also experienced times when the payment system for one of the cards was down but I was able to pay with the other.
BH