Accidental Frugality – Can You Live on Half of Your Income?
Posted by Cap in Personal Finance |Maybe you just got robbed by Zorro or maybe there’s now an unexpected child support payment (oh snap!?) — whatever the circumstances are, would you be able to live on half of your income?
A few years ago, I was reading a blog post by Trent at The Simple Dollar regarding living on half of your income, and at the time I thought to myself: “Well that’s nice. So instead of thirty Cup Noodles per month, I get to eat only fifteen? That’s totally doable.*”
(*Cool kids often use the word doable back in the days).
But time has changed. I’m now a hard-working member of society (sort of) and I’m no longer a dreadful leech on my parents (again, sort of).
Huh. I Could Have Sworn I Made More Than This…
In the past couple of months, I’ve again uprooted myself from Southern California and moved up to the San Francisco Bay Area to work on various projects, spending some good part of my time at the very cool BillShrink.com.
Being the ever disorganized person that I am, for the past few months I was being a little late on the invoicing for my contracting jobs — and by a little late, I meant a couple of months late. And when I said disorganized, what I really meant was that I was busy working hard, of course.
So in effect a good portion of my income was not flowing into my checking account. These are by no means small amounts too as they were more than enough to pay for a couple months worth of rent. Things got a bit silly when I was finally asked by the consulting clients: “When will you invoice us so we can pay you?”
Ohhh right. Money. Yeah, I need those things don’t I?
The interesting thing I noticed though was that my living standard didn’t change too much during these past couple of months — even though the cash wasn’t flowing in. You can surmise a few things from this:
- Maybe my living standard just sucks to begin with.
- Maybe I make soooo much money that half of it is still a crap load.
And the truth usually lies somewhere within the middle of those two extremes. I realized now that I do indeed have quite a no-frills life style: my expenses consist mainly of food, lodging, and transportation cost. Entertainment? Who needs to pay for entertainment when your excitement consist of weekly Settlers of Catan sessions with a fellow personal finance blogger?
Still, literally living on half of your monthly income because you forgot to ask for your paid is STUPID. When you’re not receiving your cut from the man, you’re doing yourself a major disservice: you can diminish your cash-on-hand to invest and any potential realized savings toward your retirement. Sure, timing the market is generally stupid, but missing out on tax advantages because you don’t have cash available (when you should) is even more stupid.
Having said that, being able to live on half of your income (or much less) can be great way for you to achieve your saving goals — and it is much easier thing to accomplish for recent college graduates, many of whom may go from making $0 per year to tens of thousands of dollars per year.
How to Live on Half of Your Monthly Income
- You should have a clear idea of the type of living standard you would want to enjoy. This is key, as a mortgage payment or a car loan won’t fit into the scenario unless your salary is gangbuster-high.
- You need to understand the actual expenses involved for the living standard you’ve decided to live by.
- You need to be willing to trim or cut down on certain expenses.
- You need to acutely keep a budget — unless you’re one of those type that can maintain their expenses by willpower.
- You need to understand that not everyone can live on half of their monthly income. This is especially true if you have dependents or other financial obligations. Just because some frugality tip tells you to rock a “50% savings plan” doesn’t mean that you can apply the same tactic to your life situation.
For more tips, check out this AOL coaches article: Live Your Life For Half the Price.
Regardless if you can or can’t live on half of your income, thinking about the situation can be a good mental exercise in the type of expenses you’re currently incurring. Personally, I think if you have frugal lifestyle and mentality, living on half the monthly salary will probably be a cake walk. However, if you were having issues balancing your checkbook a month or two ago, and then you suddenly decided to switch to a savings style of “living on half your income” — you probably won’t get very far.
Not a Fan of “Living on Half of Your Income”
Before you think otherwise, you should know that I am NOT a proponent of a “50% savings plan” or some “living on half your monthly income” savings tactic.
Money, at the core of it, is meant to be spent. Money affords us options and choices in life. Although I’m a pretty frugal guy, my basic financial outlook is this: If you can afford it, spend it. Just don’t be a moron and cry about it later.
I’m not a real believer in hardcore saving tactics unless its for a very specific and concrete goal (e.g. you want a house within so-and-so years). If you’re ever considering living on half of your income so you can do a 50% savings plan, you should think carefully about the trade-offs from the savings.
Sure, a vacation after a first few years of work straight out of college may be a bit lavish, but there are only certain things you can do while you’re young and have flexibility in life. Yes, maybe remodeling your entire backyard can’t be classified as a frugal move, but if you can enjoy more family time together with the new grill, patio, or jacuzzi — why not?
For some people, living on half their income is as easy as a stroll through the neighborhood (Compton, CA excluded). Their life style isn’t impacted and they’re making great headway toward their saving goals. For others, forcefully living on half their income can often be stressful and difficult. If you’re in a situation where you’re considering living on half of your salary, you need to carefully weigh the pros and cons. At the end of it, it’s all about balances and your own preferences.
What do you think about people that choose to live on half of their income? Or maybe you’re already doing it and you love it? Feel free to share your view and tips in the comments below!
24 Comments to “Accidental Frugality – Can You Live on Half of Your Income?”
Leave a Comment
Zecco Refer & Referral a Friend Program »
« Shopping For A Credit Card During A Time Of Tight Credit







September 14th, 2009 at 6:14 am
A most excellent post, sir! While I like the idea of living off 50% of one’s salary, it def takes some balls and superior financial management – something hard to keep up 24/7. I prefer the “living off of 1 salary” instead (for those who are married). And especially if you concentrate on the higher salary :)
If you can bank the rest away, you can always pull back from it whenever you’re feeling feisty and want to “live” more.
As long as people are spending less than they make though, I’m all for whatever plan works.
September 14th, 2009 at 9:37 am
Go Cap! I hope one of these gigs turns into a regular job for you! :-)
I was just thinking this morning about increasing my retirement contributions and realizing that if I drop back my take home pay to 75%, that’s what I was making 4 years ago and it should be doable.
September 14th, 2009 at 1:48 pm
I am with you. Money is here to be spent – albeit in a sensible way. For all you know, you will be too frail to enjoy your money when you are old. That is why it is important for me to strike a happy medium between saving and spending.
September 14th, 2009 at 3:46 pm
I am comfortably living on half of my income. I don’t have a mortgage so that definitely making it easier to do so. My rent is 1/3 of what a mortgage would be for the same place. With the disparity between rent and mortgage, I don’t feel like buying a place at all. If I buy a place then I definitely can not do it.
September 16th, 2009 at 10:22 am
Doing great Cap! I think it’s all about the “lifestyle”. You don’t have to make that much money to live well and happy.
A few years ago, my household made 2 to 3 times more than we make now doing the traditional 9 to 5 work. But I think we’re generally happier now because we have more flexibility and control our time (we now just “freelance”). I say “generally” because we still face the stresses of erratic income as entrepreneurs, but we do enjoy not having to face office politics anymore.
September 17th, 2009 at 5:45 am
Not buying all that stuff means you don’t need to care for or store that stuff.
It means you don’t need as much money to live which means you retire sooner or live longer. :)
Whichever.
What’s nice about having money is like you said, the options available.
For me, it’s traveling. I love to travel. But it costs money.
So, I cut back on my expenses to about $15,000 a year, but if I make $80,000 that’s all banked for my future retirement & travel.
September 18th, 2009 at 5:40 am
well, it depends on how much you make, doesn’t it? We live on about 20% of our income or $48k/yr, which allows us to live very well for us and we are in the DC area. We have increased our spending a little as our incomes increased, but we still focus on living well within the confines of only one salary, which I suppose equates to roughly 40% of one salary.
September 18th, 2009 at 7:42 am
This scenario cames down to how much you make and what kind of cost of living area you are in. Someone working at a McDonalds in New York City vs. Fargo North Dakota have extrememely different costs of living and therefore can afford to spend or save more than the other.
It’d be awesome to live off of half of my income, but for a HCOL area it’s a little difficult. (but not entirely un-doable with some fancy footwork) :-)
September 18th, 2009 at 11:54 am
When I first started my own business, we were living off practically nothing but didn’t know any better because of where we lived. They was really nothing available for purchase and we had practically no bills. Then I got a real job, and laid off and had to live off the savings for a few months which divided by the time I was out of work equated to about a third of our income, so I think its certainly doable ;)
September 18th, 2009 at 2:53 pm
this post is great. I love a frugal website that makes the point of saving but not being stupid to the point that you can no longer enjoy life. Your backyard improvement example is a good one. Some things in life may not be frugal per say, but are still worth considering.
September 25th, 2009 at 7:39 am
There is a balance of being frugal and being happy. Sometimes it means doing something for cheaper now, so that you have extra money later.
You mention “a vacation after a first few years of work straight out of college” being a bit lavish, though I have to disagree. I read a post recently about a woman who wished she had taken more time to travel abroad during the time that she was used to a lower quality of life. If you aren’t expecting to stay at a 5-star resort on all of you vacations, you can go a lot more places for less. Some people would have no problem sharing a hostel with 20 others and sleeping on a bunk above a stranger, but others, who are used to higher quality wouldn’t dream of staying somewhere without a jacuzzi. My point is, some things are best done when you don’t expect to spend a lot or don’t need to spend a lot. I advocate traveling while you are young enough to do so and you will be accustomed to spending less on the trip itself. (as long as it doesn’t mean you will be broke when you get home)
September 27th, 2009 at 1:26 pm
Oops, sorry about the above post, feel free to delete.
While I’m spending a lot of money on this trip I’m really enjoying doing things I know I won’t be able to when I’m married and with kids. I’m also ridiculously frugal most of the time so I’m not going into debt at all.
Glad you got a job and are starting to earn some ‘real’ money! Good luck!
September 28th, 2009 at 11:17 pm
Given bonuses account for anywhere between 60-80% of my total comp, I save between 60-80% of my total income since I just live off of my base.
It can be done guys! It’s just a lifestyle change.
October 1st, 2009 at 5:38 am
I understand the “idea”of living on half your income and it would be great. One could save a tremendous amount of money. I think articles like this are designed to make us really think about how we are living. The ideas motivate us to make some changes.
October 1st, 2009 at 10:15 am
Echoing what other posters have said, it really depends on where you live — I know here in the NYC metro area, we wouldn’t survive on half of our income (or on one income, as J Money noted). It’s not because we’re in over our heads — it’s because of the cost of living. I’m debating whether we should experiment with the idea of living on a certain portion of our salaries. I think it would be an excellent exercise.
October 2nd, 2009 at 11:09 pm
I try to live off half of my retirement, even since my spouse quit her job. Doable, but takes planning.
October 8th, 2009 at 1:08 am
Yes, it depends where you live and how much money you make. But regardless of anything, live within your means. Do not spend beyond your earnings. That would make living less complicated.
October 12th, 2009 at 9:21 am
I am already doing it and i like it. I dont buy stuff only to show to others or something like that. Just what i need or really want.
October 13th, 2009 at 2:30 pm
Unfortunately I’ll be learning to live on one income the hard way. Through a job loss. It is impossible though as rent and debt payments alone are more then the months take home pay. Guess the key is more income. Previously we were living on about 50% but our salaries were uneven.
October 22nd, 2009 at 8:35 pm
As a starving student, I can barely get by living on 100% of my income. I can’t imagine getting by with 50%.
November 12th, 2009 at 9:39 pm
I think the living on 50% is much easier when you don’t have dependents. When I first started out, my wife and I had no problem living off half of one of my monthly paychecks. Tiny apartment, no car, work paid for many meals, and we just didn’t see the need to live extravagantly.
Kids makes it tougher. Mortgage makes it even tougher, which you get because of Kids. The speed at which you could retire if you kept the 50% savings rate up is ridiculous. Living like that for many years can get tough though and suddenly, wham you get a house, kids, minivan, etc…..
For the average family, saving 25% of income would be a huge accomplishment. If I were single, I doubt I would spend more than 25% of my take home and I would probably be working too much.
November 19th, 2009 at 7:29 am
Learning to live on half you income is hard. In these times though it can happen instantly. When you receive a pay cut or are downsized you realize quickly what you really need to survive. It becomes a great time to forge hew spending and saving habits.
March 11th, 2010 at 1:48 pm
I live on 10% of my ‘take home’ income which is $1,000 a year. Sure I live on the street and eat garbage but I save $9,000 a year. I figure I’ll do this for about 111 years. Then I’ll be a millionaire. Then I’ll die and have a million dollar funeral.
March 11th, 2010 at 1:50 pm
i saved my drug money