What Would You Pick? Job Stability or Job Satisfaction?
Posted by Cap in Personal Finance |A person’s question:
What would you pick? Job stability or job satisfaction? I work at the local shipyard, and I was working out in the field as a shipfitter (assembling large section of ship, welding, etc.). I worked my way into the engineering department of the main officer but turns out it’s just a paper pusher, office bitch type of a job. The job was cool at first, I was physced about being inside, getting to wear regular clothes, not having to smell like ass after being in 100+ degree heat inside a 3/8-1/2″ thick steel boat structure. I’ve been doing my job, getting pay increases and whatnot but I’ve come to realize that I don’t do ANYTHING.
The person above, is 22 I think. On top of doing no real work at his job, the company staff is supposedly mostly family so you have some sort of office politics or “family only” deal going on. He wants more real substantial work, but the apparently no one will provide for it, or help him improve in his job outlook. Basically, he can do a year’s work in one week.
He’s currently looking for new work, but the job is really comfortable. The job pays very decent for doing very little challenging work. His hours are flexible and besides the mentioned problems, work environment is rather stress-free. Although the company currently has a new owner, with orders for new ships coming in, he will most likely have plenty of “work” for a long while.
So, job stability or job satisfaction? In the case here, it’s obvious he’s not satisfy with the work his job provides him with. My opinion? He should get uncomfortable again. He doesn’t have anyone else to support but himself, so it would be fairly easy for him to detach. I would easily take a pay-cut or security, for a job that provides more challenges and satisfaction. Everyone within our age bracket should strive for something a wee bit more. Perhaps I’m naive to dream for the job, but eh, a healthy dose of dreaming & striving (while you still can) isn’t so bad.
A friend of mine studying medicine told me how he’s taking classes with many people that were in a completely different field, making decent figures—but they eventually decided to go back to school because they just couldn’t live with doing what they were doing for the remainder of their lives. I asked for my friend’s opinion on the situation mentioned above.
“Look, it’s what everyone says all the time,” he told me. “Do what you truly love, and the money will follow later.”
Of course, not everyone can get up and just walk away or head back to school. If you have a family to support, things will be more difficult without additional income sources. Some will have the ability to switch their career thanks to the support of their significant others, but those that are raising a family by themselves would have a tougher outlook.
It’s a tricky situation when you end up with one of these decision, no matter the life situation you’re in. Still, my suggestion for us young’un still deciding? Get uncomfortable. It’s not so bad.
———
What would you pick? Job stability or job satisfaction?
12 Comments to “What Would You Pick? Job Stability or Job Satisfaction?”
Leave a Comment
YesMicro $5 Off Discount Code »
« Top Five Road-F’ing-Rage Cities



May 17th, 2006 at 6:35 am
Take job stability. Especially if the hours are flexible. You can always be happy in your free time!
May 17th, 2006 at 8:46 am
i’m all about job satisfaction. i worked at a job i hated for 2 years and i felt like it was sucking out every ounce of my soul. i recently quit and as soon as i did i heard of another job that seemed to fit me much better. i took a risk but it paid off. now i have job stability and job satisfaction!
May 17th, 2006 at 10:51 am
I have had both, and I’m now in a job with very little stability and a tremendous amount of satisfaction (freelance writing.) There is no question in my mind; job satisfaction wins hands-down.
If the doctor tells you that you have a terminal illness with 6 months left, what regrets would you have?
I can say that I have none. Can you?
May 17th, 2006 at 6:00 pm
I can’t get no…..Satisfaction! OK I had to do it.
Job satisfaction for me. I worked at a movie theatre(was my first job) for 6 years. It was fun at first then in the last year I hated it.
So I quit in November and now work at home. I can work on what when I want.
Feels great!
Dave
May 18th, 2006 at 5:10 am
Live your dream. Something important needs to be done and that’s why you’re here. If you’re very comfortable where you are, and the things that happen to you are routine and familar, you’re probably not living your dream.
Uncomfortable? Uncertain? People telling you you’re “nuts” or “you can’t do that”? Then you’re on the right path. Just gotta have faith.
May 18th, 2006 at 5:27 am
Great post! Tommorrow, Friday, May 19 will be last day at my job because of my whole dept. being laid off and the company moving to California. After reading your posts, I believe job satisfaction is key. Because remember you only have one life to live, so make the best of it. I will!
May 18th, 2006 at 7:09 am
I choose both too and I got both. I was a manager before and got so bored and always thought my IT skills had declined so I studied up got back in the game sent out my resume and in a month got offered a great job in development with great pay in a mid size company. Happy as can be. BUT if I have to choose 1, job stability it is, if I was on this guys shoes I’d use the other time going into fun hobbies. It’s more perspective really, flexible time, not too many challenges at work then more time to spend on other things like arts, business or health.
May 18th, 2006 at 7:48 am
Both, optimally, but if I had to choose one, it would probably be stability. Of course, I’m coming at this from a different perspective – I’m 44 and have been laid off twice from programming jobs. I tried a career change after the last layoff, found it wasn’t for me (at least the specific jobs I tried weren’t), and got back into programming. Now I have a reasonable amount of both, but if given the choice, I’d take the stability.
What was said earlier about using your free time for satisfaction is priceless. I had a very boring programming job in Denver when I lived there, but it was stable (until I got laid off after 4 years). My free time was extremely satisfying – running, hiking in the mountains, etc. I’d give almost anything to have that back, even if the job was boring.
By the way, stability could also mean a normal work schedule too. When I managed a convenience store last year, the hours were horrid (and so was the pay). The only stable thing was that I probably wasn’t going to get canned, so keep that in mind when you think of stability.
May 18th, 2006 at 8:44 am
Satisfaction, hands down. I’ve had job after job in a field in which I have a lot of talent, but no passion. I got out of it, but ended up following the money back into it. I’m about to make a jump into quite a different field, but it gives me a great deal of satisfaction.
May 22nd, 2006 at 12:12 pm
I know I took my time replying, but I actually had to give it some thought (plus busy studying my bum bums off).
What was mentioned about doing the things you love while on your free time, definitely means a lot. I mean if you have a flexible (and stable) job, why not?
Thanks for the different perspective guys, and you know what.. although I’m still touting satisfaction over stability, I think this is heavily a personal decision and varies greatly depending on the actual shoe you’re in.
But yeah… being able to enjoy your free time (or having that free time), is priceless.
February 4th, 2009 at 2:59 pm
job satisfaction any day.
up untill recently i was in a job that was very convienient for me, i.e, it was a 5 min drive away from my house, free parking, good pay, and very easy work… I dreaded going in each morning, and had to talk mself into going in. i just felt like i was continuosly wasting my time whilst i was there with nothing much to do, nor much to look forward to. After much deliberation with myself, i decided to handed in my notice. It was the best decision i had made in a long time. No regrets whatsoever, just RELIEF. Now tho i dont have all the perks of that job, i am very happy and very content in my current job. JOB SATISFACTION any day!!!